Texas Rangers relief pitcher Neal Cotts needed only a few minutes and six pitches to get three consecutive outs May 21, 2013, against the top of the Oakland A’s order. It was a nice one-inning outing for Cotts. What made it remarkable was that he was appearing in his first major league game in four years.
Cotts, who starred at Illinois State from 1999 to 2001, made his Arsenio Hall-like return against the same team that had drafted him and eight seasons after he helped the Chicago White Sox win their first World Series in 88 years. Elbow and hip injuries had kept him out of the big leagues since May 2009.
“I was really nervous, just getting back in there,” Cotts, 33, a native of Lebanon, Illinois, said in a clubhouse interview in Chicago. “Once I got the first out, everything calmed a little bit.”
The rest of the season Cotts made hitters nervous. He surrendered only seven earned runs all of last season. He had the lowest ERA (1.11) on his team and the fifth lowest ERA among American League relievers with at least 20 innings pitched. His eight wins led American League relievers.
His former Redbird head coach, Jeff Stewart, is now a San Diego Padres scout. A scout told Stewart that he thought Cotts was the best left-handed reliever in the major leagues. Stewart thought Cotts was pitching better than he did early in his career when he earned a compliment from one of that era’s top hitters.
“Rafael Palmeiro told me, ‘Stew, when Neal throws the ball, I swear it seemed like I couldn’t see it till it got to the circle. He’s deceptive,’” Stewart recalled. “He said, ‘Cotts’ 90 (mph pitch) looked like 100.’ He was pitching back then, usually like 88 to 92, while now he is 90–94, maybe bumping 95. The slider that Neal threw wasn’t a great one. And now the scouts are telling me that they think it’s a cutter. It’s an out pitch against hitters from both sides of the plate.”
Those who know Cotts well aren’t surprised by his comeback, which has garnered widespread media attention.
“One of the things that I respect about Neal is that he is a realist,” said David Bergman ’78, who is the only Redbird to be drafted higher than Cotts and the only other Redbird to play in a World Series. “When he told me, ‘David, I think I can still pitch in the big leagues’—when he says that, I absolutely believe him.”
Cotts’ return to the major leagues was as unlikely as his arrival. He didn’t think he had a shot at the pros until his junior year at Illinois State. He had been lightly recruited out of high school, and only got a look from the Redbirds because his high school coach knew then-Redbird pitching coach Tim Johnson.
But by his sophomore year Cotts had become the top pitcher on a staff that featured three other major league prospects, Stewart said.
“We knew what we had in Neal,” Stewart said.
Cotts was athletic and pitched with good deception, movement, and velocity. But the intangibles were what set him apart. Stewart said the only other player whom he had coached that could match Cotts’ competitiveness was Jeff Brantley, a former Mississippi State star who pitched for 14 seasons in the major leagues.
“Brantley was so competitive, so driven, so focused,” Stewart said. “Well, that’s Neal. When you gave Neal the ball at the beginning, he didn’t want to talk to you again until the game was over.”
Cotts’ best season at Illinois State was in 2001. He led the Redbirds to a 31-22 record, had a 2.89 ERA, and struck out 113 batters (second highest in school history). That performance persuaded the A’s to draft him in the second round.
Cotts was eventually traded to the White Sox, who brought him up to the majors in 2003 and switched him from a starting pitcher to a reliever. He had a magical 2005 season, helping the White Sox to the championship by not giving up a run in the postseason and winning Game 2 of the World Series. After the season, he was named the Setup Man of the Year.
Cotts struggled in 2006 and was traded to the Chicago Cubs the following year. He bounced between the Cubs’ major league and minor league clubs for three seasons before he hurt his elbow in 2009. Tommy John (elbow) surgery was followed by hip surgeries and a related infection. He was subsequently signed and released by the Pittsburgh Pirates and the New York Yankees.
“It was difficult after he got released,” Stewart said. “Heck, there were teams working him out, watching him throw the snot out of the ball, and nobody would do anything because of the fear that they may get involved with a workmen’s comp situation because of the hip or they might turn Neal into a cripple.”
The Yankees cut him abruptly, in 2011, after a doctor reviewed his medical record.
“They weren’t the only ones,” Cotts said. “I had a physical with the Phillies. My agent had conversations with different teams. Once the medical stuff got there, it kind of ended. In fairness to them, it’s a business; it doesn’t look real pretty probably on paper.”
Cotts took advantage of the time off by spending time with his two young children and his wife, who live in Chicago, and by working toward a finance degree at Illinois State. Cotts had been a good student during his collegiate career and was twice named to the Missouri Valley Conference’s Scholar-Athlete first team. He gave back to Illinois State by turning over a signing bonus that helped fund improvements at the University’s baseball field.
Bergman had urged Cotts to go back to school to prepare for life after baseball. Stewart had introduced the pair when Cotts was drafted so he could get advice on money matters from Bergman, a financial advisor, and the two have become good friends.
“Illinois State couldn’t have a better ambassador for the University than Neal Cotts because he is a very humble young man who has a heart of fire,” Bergman said.
Cotts held out hope for a major league return even though his agent told him he couldn’t find him a team. But then in 2012 the Rangers invited him to spring training. Cotts said the fact his agent represented the Rangers’ top prospect at the time, Jurickson Profar, may have helped him get a look from the team.
“I had no idea what was going to happen to be honest with you,” Cotts said. “I didn’t want to end it where I never ever got back on the mound and I would have been sitting at home going, ‘Well what would have happened? What could have happened?’”
Cotts almost made the major league team but got injured on the last day of spring training. He recovered and ended up pitching for the Rangers’ top minor league team in 2012. He returned healthy last year and had a microscopic 0.78 ERA in the minors when the Rangers called him up in May.
“It’s been exciting,” Cotts said. “You never think about it as a hard job or hard to come back from. I just always wanted to get back out there and compete and see if my body could hold up. It was a challenge.”
The Rangers ended their season by losing a one-game playoff for a Wild Card spot, a game in which Cotts threw another scoreless inning. The Rangers and Cotts agreed to a one-year, $2.2 million contract in January.
“Remember now, he’s got a fresh arm,” Bergman said. “He could pitch another six, seven, eight years.”
What a strange trip it’s been
June 5, 2001: Drafted 69th overall by the Oakland Athletics, making him the second highest draft pick in Illinois State history.
December 16, 2002: Traded to the Chicago White Sox.
August 12, 2003: Makes major league debut at age 23, a start in which he gives up two runs in 2.1 innings.
October 26, 2005: Wins World Series as a key reliever for the White Sox.
December 15 , 2005: Wins Setup Man of the Year Award for season in which he finishes 4-0 with a 1.94 ERA.
November 16, 2006: Traded to the Chicago Cubs.
July 2009: Undergoes season-ending Tommy John surgery. Doesn’t pitch in another big league game until 2013.
January 4, 2010: Signed by the Pittsburgh Pirates.
June 2010: Undergoes hip surgery.
November 19, 2010: Signed by the New York Yankees.
February 20, 2012: Signed by Texas Rangers to a minor league contract.
April 3, 2012: Assigned to Texas Rangers’ top minor league team after injuring left lat muscle.
May 21, 2013: Pitches scoreless inning for Texas Rangers in first major league appearance in four years.
September 30, 2013: Finishes season with 8-3 record and 1.11 ERA.
October 5, 2013: Named a finalist for the Hutch Award, given annually to player who displays honor, courage, and dedication.
January 15, 2014: Cotts agrees to a one-year, $2.2 million contract with Rangers.