Watershed moment: Scholar’s studies on lakes worldwide sound environmental alarm
As the sun slowly rises across the horizon, heat emanates from the red earth as Catherine O’Reilly makes her way down a path on the outskirts of Kigoma, Tanzania. Schoolchildren run past, dressed in uniforms faded from too many washes and the dust that constantly sweeps through the air. Cresting a hill, O’Reilly sees the sparkling morning light catch the expansive water of Lake Tanganyika—a source of life and livelihood for tens of millions of people.
“It’s stunningly, stunningly beautiful,” said O’Reilly. The aquatic ecologist and associate professor of geology at Illinois State has been working with the Tanzania Fisheries Research Institute (TAFIRI) for decades to study the lake, which spans 400 miles wide and dives a mile deep. “In the wet season, the lake stretches out flat like glass. You can’t see across to the other side, but you can see the clouds reflected perfectly. It is a beauty that cannot be described.”
Like many lakes around the globe, the life that teems in and around Lake Tanganyika is at risk. The impact of rising temperatures on the freshwater lake can be viewed in the increasingly sparse catches of local fishermen. They are not alone.
Climate change is robbing millions of people around the lake of food and livelihood as the fish population disappears. O’Reilly has been studying the phenomenon for three decades. In 2007 she was part of a team of scientists honored with a Nobel Peace Prize for sounding the alarm about the irreversible danger to freshwater ecosystems caused by increasing temperatures.
“It’s horrifying to see people being so affected by something that they didn’t cause,” O’Reilly said. “These are not the people who are responsible for climate change, yet they’re the ones being affected by it.”
Lake Tanganyika is the longest and second-oldest freshwater lake in the world, forming part of the borders of Tanzania, Burundi, Zambia, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The Tanzania Fisheries Research Institute (TAFIRI) lies along the shore of Kigoma, where O’Reilly first ventured while pursuing her doctorate in the 1990s. She returned with a research education grant from the National Science Foundation (NSF) to spend another five years at TAFIRI, working alongside students from the United States and Tanzania. “The one thing I didn’t want was to just plop ourselves down there, do our own work, and leave,” said O’Reilly. “The local scientists know the lake. They know the fishermen and the people. It’s amazing what you can find out when you work together.”
TAFIRI Director Ismael Aaron Kimirei has known O’Reilly since 2004, when they met while she was an instructor and he was a student at Lake Tanganyika. He credits O’Reilly with working in a spirit of mutual respect since she arrived in East Africa. “We both have the urge to build the research capacity of not only TAFIRI staff, but other underprivileged researchers,” he said. “My lab is in better shape partly because of our collaboration, but most importantly from her initiative.” The two continue to collaborate on the Projections of Climate Change Effects on Lake Tanganyika project with Peter Staehr from the University of Aarhus in Denmark, as well as on several other international research projects.
When visiting Tanzania, O’Reilly and a local team go onto Lake Tanganyika to check the status of a massive buoy equipped with devices to measure lake temperatures. Data flows from the buoy moored to the bottom of the lake back to a facility on the shore where the numbers are processed and analyzed. The team tries to time the trips on the lake to avoid storms brought by the wet season and large waves stirred up by the dry season. “During the dry season, the wind is intense, and the waves can be many feet high,” O’Reilly said. “It’s actually a bit like Lake Superior or Lake Michigan in that it can be dangerous.”
O’Reilly is known internationally as an expert in the field of freshwater ecology. She has garnered millions of dollars in research grants from the NSF, NASA, the Danish International Development Agency, the Nutrient Research and Education Council, and the Environmental Protection Agency. She recently helped lead a team that is predicting the loss of ice on nearly 350 lakes in the Northern Hemisphere that could impact more than 650 million people. “We’re not talking about lakes getting a little warmer. We are talking about lake ice being gone in the winter,” she said. “Our children and grandchildren would not see something we have taken for granted.”
Her work has been highlighted in The New York Times, BBC, The Guardian, The Christian Science Monitor, The Washington Post, and National Geographic. A 2003 paper on Lake Tanganyika that was published in Nature helped earn O’Reilly a Nobel Peace Prize. She shared the award as one of the scientists on the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. “I like to say I have 1/2000th of one half of a Nobel Peace Prize,” joked O’ Reilly. She is one of four international leaders of the Global Lake Temperature Collaboration, which gathered one of the most extensive collections of data on freshwater lakes ever seen. The study, published in 2015 in Geophysical Research Letters, pulled in analyses of 235 freshwater lakes—more than half of the world’s freshwater supply.
For the groundbreaking study, funded by NASA and the NSF, O’Reilly drew together 64 world-renowned scientists who shared up to 30 years’ worth of data on lake temperatures. “When people ask about the scope of the project, my mind slips back to the more than 4,000 emails we all exchanged,” said O’Reilly. “Four thousand, eight hundred, and seventy-six, to be exact.” Electronic conversations flew over the course of the five-year study, involving scholars from Denmark to New Zealand.
The emphasis on collaboration cemented the success of the project, noted co-leader Sapna Sharma, a research chair in global change biology at York University in Canada. “Catherine is exactly the type of researcher with whom you want to work,” she said. “She is an inclusive leader who brings everyone’s voice to the work, keeps it moving forward, and takes the time to ensure the research is of the highest quality.”
Sharma and O’Reilly are expanding their work examining freshwater to include which lakes might no longer freeze due to rising temperatures. “Warming lakes, in particular, have large ramifications for water quality, which is essential for human survival,” said Sharma.
In other words: As goes the freshwater, so goes the human race.
Danger in degrees
The shared data from the Global Lake Temperature Collaboration originated from satellite measurements and scientists on the ground. “Satellites can gather temperatures from large lakes in remote places of the world, and have been for the last 25 years. But they can’t find the small lakes,” said O’Reilly. “That’s when you need the people out doing the sampling.” O’Reilly turned to the scientists in the field, individuals who have collected data across the decades on smaller lakes. The results led to a discovery: The mean temperature of lakes worldwide is escalating quickly. Between 1985 and 2009, the study found lakes are warming an average of 0.61 degrees Fahrenheit (0.34 degrees Celsius) each decade.
A less-than-one-degree change in temperature doesn’t sound like much. For the planet, however, a one-degree change in the average temperature is extraordinary. When it comes to warming of lake temperatures, what once took centuries is now taking a little over 10 years to achieve, or the geophysical equivalent of a blink of an eye. “We’re talking about an average number, which means some places are warming up much more than that. Those places are going to be seeing a lot of changes,” said O’Reilly.
For Lake Tanganyika, rising temperatures mean a simple shift: Fish are disappearing. The impact of that change is not so simple. TAFIRI estimates that more than 60 million people in the four countries bordering Lake Tanganyika rely on fish as their main source of protein and the lake itself for freshwater.
The surrounding population has been increasing, around 4.5 percent over the last 15 years—twice Tanzania’s growth rate. “People are looking to the shorelines for fish—both for a job and for sustenance—exactly at a time when climate change is robbing fish from the lake,” said O’Reilly.
Fish get a double whammy as warming temperatures also spur the growth of a special algae that produces toxins. “It’s a group of algae called cyanobacteria or blue-green algae,” said O’Reilly. “They have little gas vesicles in them, so that keeps them up near the surface of the water, which is right where they want to be because that’s where the sunlight is. So they’re very good at floating and multiplying.” Some of those algae produce cyanotoxins, which can be harmful to people and other mammals. The study predicts a 5 percent growth of these toxic blooms if temperature growth remains the same.
There are no easy solutions to these problems. “You have these conversations with people, explaining how the lake is changing, warming up, and what that does. And then they’ll ask, ‘Well, what can we do about it?’” said O’Reilly. “And you kind of have to say, ‘Well, very little. Because you alone can’t fix this problem.’”
She believes an adaptive fisheries management program would help, but any large-scale efforts are hindered by international borders. “There are four countries involved when it comes to Lake Tanganyika,” said O’Reilly. “It would take a lot of political will to manage. But something has to be done or the fish population will collapse, and there will be lots and lots of hungry people out there. And hunger can lead to unrest.”
Closer to home
Thousands of miles from the African lakeshore, O’Reilly is employing the same drive to bring disparate voices together to help improve water quality in Central Illinois. For several years O’Reilly, Associate Professor of Biology William Perry, and Professor of Geology Eric Peterson have worked with the City of Bloomington to install water-monitoring stations at Six-Mile Creek and Money Creek, tributaries that flow directly into the reservoirs that supply the city’s water.
The systems were the latest effort in an ongoing collaboration between the city and the University to monitor and improve water quality in the area. “We’re working together to understand how to change land management in a sustainable fashion within agriculture-intensive areas,” said Perry.
Related Article: Professor Catherine O'Reilly receives $1.7 million grant to fund project that will help students and faculty work with large data sets.
The scientists speak with Central Illinois farmers about cover crops, which are grown to enrich the soil, to protect it from erosion, and to prevent the leeching of fertilizer and nitrogen into waterways. “We approached working with farmers differently,” O’Reilly said. “In a lot of cover crop projects done by scientists, they want to control everything because … well … they are scientists.” O’Reilly noted project organizers tend to dictate to farmers the timing of planting and watering, as well as the amount of fertilizer used. “Our project was much more saying to farmers, ‘Do whatever you would normally do, plus add a cover crop in the fall.’”
The approach mirrors the methods she developed since her early days at Lake Tanganyika. “Farmers know their land. They have expertise in understanding how the land will react,” said O’Reilly. “Plus, it just works better when people work together.”
O’Reilly is also among a group of faculty establishing a Center for Sustainable Water Future at Illinois State. The center will encourage long-term water solutions through academic research, and teaching and learning opportunities from across campus disciplines.
For O’Reilly, no matter where the water lies, the impact is the same. Freshwater is essential for human life, and she sees the challenges that climate change presents to freshwater lakes as a worldwide danger. “There’s a whole series of lakes out there, and they’re all going to be changing. We need to prepare for that,” said O’Reilly.
Rachel Hatch can be reached at rkhatch@IllinoisState.edu.